Canvas YG vs. Reg YG

[parco10]

Good day fellow collectors. I haven't been that active in the hobby for the last couple years so I'm a little out of the loop. I recently busted a couple boxes of extended and got a Schaefer Canvas YG. I don't collect canvas and have no use for the card so I was thinking of offering it for trade for his regular YG, however I have no idea of the BV/TV of either card. I checked ebay sold listings and the Canvas seems to be selling for a slight premium.

Was wondering what the communities thoughts/opinions were on these values? Would a straight up 1 for 1 swap be reasonable? Or does one actually demand a premium?

Thanks for reading and I look forward to your responses.

 

[will-411]

My thoughts, Canvas in general start out strong, but they have a narrower appeal, so their top end pricing tends to fade out quicker. My personal opinion? I'd trade a Canvas YG for the regular all day long, straight up, despite the Canvas being harder to pull. Remembering too that technically, a Canvas YG is a rookie year card, not recognized by all as a Rookie Card.

Cory